Visit Oh! BabyOpinionated Parenting

Thursday, September 29, 2005

As many times as Toddler in Chief has watched the episode "Blue goes to the Doctor," taking him in for vaccines is about as fun as scraping my knuckles along a cheese grater. Even though his pal Blue got the shot with hardly a whimper, my son screams, sobs, and projects sounds of assorted frequencies. Plus, he's two, and he just doesn't quite grasp the concept "it will hurt, but it's good for you." He can't understand why Mom and Dad hold him down while a stranger in a lab coat jabs him with large needles. It just sucks for everyone.

Yes, there's guilt from letting my kid spend a few minutes in the life of a pin cushion, but imagine the guilt if he ended up in the hospital with a preventable disease, like Hepatitis B, Diphtheria, or Measles. Giving your kid vaccines keeps them healthier. And parents who choose not to vaccinate their kids are taking unnecessary risks with their kid's health, and even their lives.

It's true that many of the diseases that we vaccinate against are rare. For example, there has been no case of Polio in the United States for more than 20 years. Still, it is prevalent in other parts of the world. Currently, there are outbreaks in Yemen and Somalia, and the World Health Organization launched a polio immunization campaign on September 13, to slow its spread.

No, my kid isn't going to Africa or the Middle East anytime in the foreseeable future, but if there is a chance--any chance--that my kid could acquire this or any other debilitating and life-threatening diseases, then I'm going for it. This goes for every possible vaccine, even if it means a few minutes of tears. One can argue that there are risks associated with vaccines and it's just not worth it, especially when the diseases are rare. But I'm not taking any chances.

Just as I slather my kid in sunscreen, use antibacterial soap, and marvel at that surface made from recycled tires that has replaced cement at the playground, I'm grateful for any advances--medical or otherwise--that keep my kid healthy and out of harm's way.

Permalink | Vaccinations | Comments (9)

Comments

"One can argue that there are risks associated with vaccines and it's just not worth it, especially when the diseases are rare. But I'm not taking any chances."

But you -are- taking a chance. You're taking the chance that the vaccines won't damage your kid. While it's a small risk, it is a risk, and it's something to consider, not just throw aside, and not even consider it a chance. We all take chances on the vaccines issue, it's just a matter of which chances you're willing to take.

Posted by: Jeremiah Lee | Sep 30, 2005 7:06:03 PM

You say you're not taking any chances? What are you nuts? You have no idea what the shot being given to your child is going to do to them. Prevent a disease, maybe. Seriously harm them, maybe. The fact is, no one knows. You are listening to a doctor that has no idea what the shot will do either. The doctor is listeng to some crap they learned in med school. They are just doing what they are told and it sounds like you are as well. I hope you did your research like "laid off Dad" suggests. One question... Would you willingly inject the stuff in these vaccines into yourself and take the risks you are taking with your child?

Posted by: just some dad | Oct 3, 2005 1:36:59 PM

Just Some Dad -- weren't you vaccinated as a child? I was, and to date, no evidence of any negative effects. In fact, I don't personally know anyone who feels that a childhood vaccine led to health problems later (I'm sure they're out there, I just don't know them). I do, however, know two people whose doctors believe that untreated, preventable childhood diseases led to progressive disabilities as adults. With that kind of life experience, is it unreasonable that I would choose a pediatrician who promotes vaccination?

Yes, the vaccines have risks. But it is not irresponsible parenting to decide that the diseases are riskier.

Posted by: Julie | Oct 4, 2005 9:45:43 AM

A case of polio was recently reported in Minnesota. This case stems from a child not being vaccinated, then exposed to a person that was previously given oral vaccination, which is killed polio virus as opposed to a synthesis. This case could have been prevented had the child been vaccinated.

Minneapolis Star Tribune 10/4/05:
http://www.startribune.com/stories/484/5649776.html

Posted by: Anna | Oct 4, 2005 1:22:30 PM

When we take our daughter in for a check-up that includes a scheduled vaccination, we get a flyer that talks about the advantages and potential problems... but by that time we've already researched the issue and made our decision. Vaccinations are a personal decision, one that requires due care and consideration.

What I find funny is Toddler in Chief throwing a fit at receiving a shot. Hey, my 15-month-old throws a fit for merely being in the doctor's office, shots or not.

Posted by: AJ | Oct 4, 2005 5:09:38 PM

And as far as vaccinations--we did them. All of them. Did I
feel pressured to do so? No. Did my doctor recommend them? Yep.
He's got 20-odd years of service. I'll take him up on it--and I trust him.

Whether he is told to recommend them or not, I know I was given every vaccination under the sun, and here I stand (err...type). So, although there is some risk involved with the shots, I'd take the odds against a terrible disease.

Posted by: bethany | Oct 4, 2005 7:01:10 PM

I couldn't have said it better myself. I'm pro-vaccination, and personally can't understand people that are against it. The benefits FAR outweigh the risks here.

Posted by: andrea | Oct 5, 2005 9:21:45 AM

"Giving your kid vaccines keeps them healthier. And parents who choose not to vaccinate their kids are taking unnecessary risks with their kid's health, and even their lives."

I work in a Pediatric ED - the biggest and most prestigious one in our country - and I see first hand the risks of not immunizing kids. Just ask the mother I took care of last year who now has permentant brain damage because her child passed Measles along to her and she was too old to have ever been immunized. Or the parents of the young babies who spend week in ICu almost dying from Whooping Cough because one of their neighbours kids wasn't immunized and gave it to a baby who was too young to have had their shots.

A child screams for a few minutes when you immunize them. Maybe, if you're unlucky, they cry for a day or two and get a mild fever. if you don't immuniza them you run the risk of watching them died from terrible diseases and then burying them. I know what I'd prefer.

Posted by: Eden Shadlow | Oct 5, 2005 11:54:16 AM

This issue is trivialized when pro-vaccine parents mention the rare cases of unvaccinated kids getting these diseases, without acknowledging the equally rare cases of vaccinated kids having equally serious complications because of the vaccines that were supposed to protect them. That is, after all, why vaccines are a point of contention. Parents who don't give their kids certain vaccines aren't stupid or uncaring. There are risks on both sides of the issue that need to be weighed.

Posted by: AJ | Oct 6, 2005 1:34:34 PM

The comments to this entry are closed.